Our critics provide thoughtful analysis of alternative comedy performances, specials, albums, and shows. We evaluate work based on innovation, execution, and contribution to the evolving landscape of alternative comedy.

Filter Reviews

Latest Performance Reviews

"Delirious Structures" by James Acaster

Venue: Soho Theatre, London

Dates: March 1-15, 2025

★★★★★

James Acaster continues to reinvent what a comedy show can be with his latest offering "Delirious Structures." Building on the conceptual frameworks that have become his trademark, Acaster's new show explores the arbitrary rules that govern social interaction through a series of interconnected vignettes.

What distinguishes this show from his previous work is the increased multimedia elements—projected animations, soundscapes, and even moments of audience-collaborative storytelling create an immersive experience that goes beyond traditional stand-up.

The show's highlight comes in its final third, when Acaster reveals how each seemingly disparate segment connects to form a cohesive commentary on contemporary British politics without ever being explicitly political. It's a masterclass in layered comedy writing that rewards attentive viewing without alienating more casual audience members.

"Delirious Structures" cements Acaster's position as one of the most innovative voices in contemporary alternative comedy—a performer who continues to push the boundaries of the form while remaining fundamentally hilarious.

Read Full Review

"Digital Detox" by Patti Harrison

Venue: Dynasty Typewriter, Los Angeles

Dates: February 14-16, 2025

★★★★½

Patti Harrison's latest hour "Digital Detox" seamlessly blends surrealist character work with incisive commentary on technology and identity. Harrison begins the show by confiscating audience members' phones, a move that initially seems like a simple gimmick but becomes integral to the show's increasingly bizarre narrative.

Over 75 minutes, Harrison transforms from a wellness guru parodying digital detox culture into a series of increasingly unhinged characters, each representing different aspects of our relationship with technology. Particularly effective is a segment where she embodies an AI assistant becoming gradually more sentient and disturbed by human behavior.

What elevates "Digital Detox" beyond mere satire is Harrison's willingness to implicate herself in the digital dependencies she critiques. Moments of surprising vulnerability punctuate the absurdism, creating a show that is as thought-provoking as it is consistently hilarious.

While occasional transitions between segments feel abrupt, the overall effect is of a comedian operating at the height of her powers, unafraid to experiment with form while remaining connected to genuine emotional resonance.

Read Full Review

"The Collective Unconscious" by The Asymmetricals

Venue: Terra Kulture, Lagos

Dates: January 20-26, 2025

★★★★★

Nigerian comedy collective The Asymmetricals have created something genuinely unprecedented with "The Collective Unconscious," a two-hour performance that blends traditional African storytelling techniques with absurdist comedy and multimedia elements.

The seven-member ensemble moves fluidly between scripted scenes, improvisation, musical interludes, and audience interaction, creating a show that feels both meticulously crafted and thrillingly spontaneous. Their exploration of Nigerian identity in a globalized world manages to be politically insightful without ever becoming didactic.

Particularly effective is their use of multiple languages throughout the show—switching between English, Yoruba, Igbo, and Pidgin—creating layers of understanding for different audience segments while using translation as a comedic device in itself.

What's most remarkable about "The Collective Unconscious" is how it creates a form of alternative comedy that doesn't simply import Western alt comedy traditions but develops something culturally specific and original. This is boundary-pushing work that deserves international attention.

Read Full Review

Special Features and Retrospectives

Alt Comedy Albums: The Best Recorded Alternative Comedy

By Sarah Kim | March 15, 2025

While live performance remains the primary medium for alternative comedy, recorded albums provide both documentation and a different creative avenue for alt comedians. This feature explores the best alternative comedy albums of the past decade, examining how different performers adapt their work for audio-only formats.

Read Feature

25 Years Later: Remembering "Mr. Show with Bob and David"

By Marcus Washington | February 28, 2025

A quarter-century after its final HBO episode aired, this retrospective examines the enduring influence of "Mr. Show with Bob and David" on alternative comedy. Through interviews with contemporary comedians and analysis of specific sketches, the article traces how Bob Odenkirk and David Cross's creation helped establish a blueprint for alternative sketch comedy that continues to influence creators today.

Read Feature

The New Vanguard: 10 Alternative Comedians Redefining the Form

By Jordan Richards | January 30, 2025

This feature profiles ten emerging alternative comedians who are pushing comedy in new directions. Rather than simply listing performers, the article examines the specific innovations each brings to comedy and how they reflect broader cultural and technological shifts.

Read Feature

Our Review Methodology

At AltComedy.com, we approach reviews with an understanding that alternative comedy often deliberately subverts traditional evaluation criteria. Our reviewers consider:

  • Innovation: How the work pushes boundaries or introduces new approaches
  • Execution: How effectively the performer realizes their creative vision
  • Context: How the work relates to both comedy traditions and contemporary culture
  • Audience Experience: The intended effect versus the actual impact on viewers

Our rating system uses a five-star scale:

★★★★★ - Exceptional: Groundbreaking work that significantly advances alternative comedy

★★★★ - Excellent: Innovative, technically accomplished, and consistently engaging

★★★ - Good: Solid work with notable strengths, though not revolutionary

★★ - Fair: Shows potential but has significant shortcomings

- Poor: Fails to achieve its aims or lacks originality